Skip to main content
 

PHIL3211: Biomedical Ethics Past and Present

Please ensure you check the module availability box for each module outline, as not all modules will run in each academic year. Each module description relates to the year indicated in the module availability box, and this may change from year to year, due to, for example: changing staff expertise, disciplinary developments, the requirements of external bodies and partners, and student feedback. Current modules are subject to change in light of the ongoing disruption caused by Covid-19.

Type Open
Level 3
Credits 20
Availability Available in 2023/24
Module Cap None.
Location Durham
Department Philosophy

Prerequisites

  • Either Moral Theory (PHIL2041) or Philosophy of Science (PHIL2151) or History, Science and Medicine (PHIL2191).

Corequisites

  • At least one other 'Year 3' module in Philosophy.

Excluded Combinations of Modules

  • None

Aims

  • To understand biomedical ethics in historical and present contexts and to see how ethical standards have developed in certain fields of Western Medicine.

Content

  • The following main topics will typically be studied: professional conduct and its codifications from the Hippocratic oath to the codes of the nineteenth century and the General Medical Council, the controversy over animal experimentation since the seventeenth century, the development of guidelines for research on human beings, changing attitudes towards death and euthanasia, abortion and reproductive technologies, the issues of informed consent and medical confidentiality.

Learning Outcomes

Subject-specific Knowledge:

  • By the end of the module students will have knowledge and understanding of the historical aspects and current key arguments regarding the following ethical issues in medicine:
  • Codes of professional medical conduct
  • Animal experimentation
  • Research on Human Subjects
  • Death and Euthanasia
  • Abortion and Reproduction
  • Informed Consent
  • Medical Confidentiality

Subject-specific Skills:

  • grasp, analyse, evaluate and deploy subject-specific concepts and arguments
  • locate, understand, assess and utilise pertinent philosophical and historical sources
  • Interpret and criticise relevant texts.

Key Skills:

  • express themselves clearly and succinctly in writing and discussion
  • comprehend complex ideas, propositions and theories
  • defend their opinions by reasoned argument
  • seek out and identify appropriate sources of evidence and information
  • tackle problems in a clear-sighted and logical fashion

Modes of Teaching, Learning and Assessment and how these contribute to the learning outcomes of the module

  • Seminars will provide the opportunity for students to present their own work in progress, to test their understanding of the course material, and defend and debate different opinions on theories and questions presented in that material.
  • Guided reading provides a structure within which students exercise and extend their abilities to make use of available learning resources.
  • The summative essays test knowledge and understanding of the course material, and the ability to identify and explain philosophical questions raised by the natural and medical sciences, and, using relevant research material, to present relevant philosophical theories and arguments that claim to answer those questions, and to make reasoned judgements on the merits and demerits of such theories.

Teaching Methods and Learning Hours

ActivityNumberFrequencyDurationTotalMonitored
Seminars22weekly 2 hours44 
Preparation and Reading 156 
Total200 

Summative Assessment

Component: EssayComponent Weighting: 33.34%
ElementLength / DurationElement WeightingResit Opportunity
Essay 1, including footnotes but excluding bibliography2000 words100 
Component: Essay Component Weighting: 33.33%
ElementLength / DurationElement WeightingResit Opportunity
Essay 2, including footnotes but excluding bibliography2000 words100 
Component: Essay Component Weighting: 33.33%
ElementLength / DurationElement WeightingResit Opportunity
Essay 3, including footnotes but excluding bibliography2000 words100 

Formative Assessment

An oral presentation (20min short paper) in class on one of the three essay topics.

More information

If you have a question about Durham's modular degree programmes, please visit our FAQ webpages, Help page or our glossary of terms. If you have a question about modular programmes that is not covered by the FAQ, or a query about the on-line Undergraduate Module Handbook, please contact us.

Prospective Students: If you have a query about a specific module or degree programme, please Ask Us.

Current Students: Please contact your department.